Netflix Best Scary Movies to Test Your Limits (2023)

Cold weather, earlier sunsets, and a free evening often add up to one question: “What should I watch?” If you lean toward horror, Netflix has plenty of options, yet scrolling can feel endless. The list below gathers eight movies that cover different corners of the genre, from psychological dread to creature scares, so you can spend less time browsing and more time enjoying the show.

The write‑ups go a bit deeper than basic synopses. Each section explains the film’s main hook, notes anything viewers sometimes overlook, and suggests the best setting or mood for hitting Play. Use it as a guide for a solo night, a group stream, or even a weekly mini‑marathon. Grab a horror-inspired tumbler and get started!

This proven list of the top 8 best scary movies on Netflix is sure to leave you feeling haunted

8) The Invitation (2015)

IMDb 6.6, Rotten Tomatoes 88%

Will and girlfriend Kira drive to the Hollywood Hills for dinner at the home of Will’s ex‑wife Eden and her new husband David. Other friends from their old circle arrive. Conversation feels polite but stilted, and the hosts keep hinting at a transformative experience they want everyone to join.

Why it stands out

• Slow‑burn suspense: For an hour, almost nothing overtly scary happens. Unease builds from missed glances, locked doors, and offhand remarks.

• Trauma angle: Will’s own grief clouds his perception, so viewers question whether the danger is real or imagined.

• Explosive finale: The last twenty minutes justify the patience with a payoff both shocking and, in hindsight, inevitable.

Watching suggestion: Avoid phones; distractions break the tension. If you like to guess twists, keep mental notes of every small detail.

7) Crimson Peak (2015)

IMDb 6.5, Rotten Tomatoes 72%

Edith marries the charming Thomas Sharpe and moves into his decaying English mansion, Allerdale Hall. Blood‑red clay oozes through floorboards, and the wind moans through broken windows. Edith hears whispers warning her to leave.

Why it stands out

• Art direction: Director Guillermo del Toro fills every frame with texture; moths on wallpaper, snow drifting through broken roofs, candlelight on velvet.

• Gothic romance: Expect more tragic love story than slasher. Ghosts appear, but their purpose may not be simple harm.

• Performance trio: Mia Wasikowska, Tom Hiddleston, and Jessica Chastain bring nuance to roles that could have been one‑note.

Note on scares: The film has brutal moments, yet overall it leans atmospheric. It is a good bridge pick for viewers who like spooky mood but avoid hardcore gore.

6) It Follows (2020)

IMDb 6.8, Rotten Tomatoes 96%

After an uneasy date, college student Jay discovers she is cursed: a shape‑shifting figure will pursue her at walking speed until it catches and kills her. She can pass the curse by sleeping with someone else, but if that person dies the entity returns to her.

Why it stands out

• Relentless rules: The monster never speeds up, never teleports, and never stops. The simplicity makes it believable and terrifying.

• Retro vibe: Synth music, wide shots, and ambiguous time period create a dreamlike feeling.

• Moral ambiguity: The curse passes through intimacy, prompting questions about responsibility, consent, and fear.

Best approach: Watch late, with lights low. The steady pace works better when you can sink into a quiet environment.

5) The Ritual (2018)

IMDb 6.3, Rotten Tomatoes 73%

Four university friends reunite for a memorial hike after one of their group is killed during a robbery. They cut through an unmarked Scandinavian forest to save time. Rain starts, night falls, and something large screams in the distance.

Why it stands out

• Folklore twist: The creature design draws from Nordic myth, offering a break from typical movie monsters.

• Group dynamics: Old resentments surface under stress, making human conflict as dangerous as the thing in the woods.

• Visual payoff: When the full beast finally appears, it is one of the more creative practical‑effects reveals in recent years.

Pro tip: If you enjoy pairing films, double this with 2015’s The Witch for a dark‑woods folk‑horror evening.

4) Hush (2016)

IMDb 6.6, Rotten Tomatoes 93%

Author Maddie has been deaf since her teens and now lives in a secluded house in the woods. A masked stranger appears outside and realizes quickly that his target cannot hear him. What follows is a nearly real‑time siege.

Why it stands out

• Sound strategy: The audio track flips between Maddie’s silent perspective and normal ambient sound. That switch keeps viewers hyper‑aware of every footstep and door hinge.

• Economic storytelling: At eighty‑two minutes, there is no filler. Each action beat forces Maddie to adapt, making her easy to root for.

• Inventive cat‑and‑mouse: The screenplay treats deafness as a challenge and a tool rather than a weakness; several tense reversals come from skills the killer lacks.

Ideal setting: Turn up your TV or wear headphones so you catch the subtle design choices. Low lighting helps too, since many cues are visual.

3) The Babadook (2014)

IMDb 6.8, Rotten Tomatoes 93%

Amelia is a widowed mother raising her hyperactive six‑year‑old Samuel. Exhaustion hangs over their house like dust. When a strange picture book titled “Mister Babadook” appears on the shelf, Samuel becomes convinced something is coming for them.

Why it stands out

• Emotional core: Director Jennifer Kent treats grief and parental burnout as seriously as any ghost. The result feels painfully real.

• Minimal effects: Practical shadows, harsh lighting, and sound design make the monster scarier than expensive CGI ever could.

• Ambiguous end: The last ten minutes spark debate—interpretation can change based on your own experiences with loss or mental health.

Family note: Despite centering on a child, this is not kid‑friendly. Save it for an adult night when you are ready for a heavier story.

2) Midsommar (2019)

IMDb 7.1, Rotten Tomatoes 83%

Director Ari Aster follows a grieving couple and their friends to a remote Swedish commune that hosts a festival once every ninety years. Traditions start with folk dances and flower crowns before taking an unsettling turn.

Why it stands out

• Daylight dread: Nearly every scene happens under bright summer sun, proving horror can thrive without shadows.

• Slow boil: At two and a half hours, the movie takes its time. Rituals grow stranger in small increments, and when the shock finally lands it feels earned.

• Relationship focus: Beneath the cult plot is a breakup story. Watching emotional cracks widen adds a second, more personal layer of tension.

Viewing tip: The film is graphic in both violence and sexuality. If you are squeamish, consider keeping the remote handy. Watching with friends can help, since reactions often spark long discussions afterward.

1) Get Out (2017)

IMDb 7.7, Rotten Tomatoes 98%

Jordan Peele’s debut feature has already become modern canon. Photographer Chris goes home with his girlfriend Rose to meet her parents at their comfortable upstate house. Small social missteps, awkward comments about race, over‑friendly hugs, start piling up. What feels like a cringe comedy of manners turns into something far darker.

Why it stands out

• Layered storytelling: Peele hides clues in casual dialogue, family photos, and party chatter, which makes a repeat viewing rewarding.

• Genre blend: The movie jumps from satire to suspense to classic monster‑movie tension without losing momentum.

• Payoff: A late‑film reveal reframes nearly every earlier scene, yet the finale remains suspenseful even when you know what is coming.

Good to know: Language and violence push this closer to an R‑rated thriller than light horror. It is also talk‑heavy early on, so watch when you have time to settle in rather than during a distracted evening.

RECAP:

1. Get Out

2. Midsommar

3. The Babadook

4. Hush

5. The Ritual

6. It Follows

7. Crimson Peak

8. The Invitation

Program Your Own Scare Schedule

If you are looking to stretch the fun over several nights, try this order:

1. Thursday – Crimson Peak (moody but not too intense)

2. Friday – The Ritual (weekend kickoff with creature thrills)

3. Saturday double bill – It Follows followed by Get Out (modern classics, different energies)

4. Sunday afternoon – Hush (short runtime, keeps adrenaline up)

5. Next Thursday – The Invitation (slow sip of dread)

6. Weekend capstone – Midsommar and The Babadook back‑to‑back for emotional heavy hitters

   
   

Adjust as you like. Horror plays best when matched to mood: daylight folk terror for Sunday brunch, shadowy slashers for midnight.

A Final Word Before You Press Play

Netflix’s library changes, so verify each title is still available in your region. Use subtitles when possible, many of these films rely on subtle sound cues or quiet dialogue. Dim the lights, grab your horror tumbler, silence notifications, and keep a blanket nearby if you like hiding behind something during the tense parts.

Whether you prefer cerebral chills, ghastly romance, or a good old monster in the woods, this lineup should keep the dark nights interesting. Happy watching, and may your popcorn stay firmly in the bowl, at least until the next jump scare.

Horror Tumblers